7 Best Air Fryer Donut Pans of 2026

Crisp, golden donuts with zero fuss—that’s the promise of the NutriChef carbon steel donut pans, and they deliver with authority. Built from durable carbon steel, these pans offer exceptional heat retention and distribution, ensuring your donuts bake evenly without hot spots or undercooked centers. The PFOA-free non-stick coating is a game-changer, allowing delicate pastries to release cleanly—no more torn edges or frustrating residue. For bakers tired of flimsy, warped pans that degrade after a few uses, this set answers the call with industrial-grade resilience and consistent performance.

In real-world testing, these trays shine in standard ovens and toaster ovens alike, producing full-sized, bakery-quality donuts that rise evenly and brown uniformly. Measuring 12.5 x 8.5 inches, they fit comfortably in most ovens without crowding, and their 450°F heat tolerance opens the door to everything from cinnamon sugar rings to savory bagel-style bakes. While they’re not designed for air fryers (due to size and rigidity), they excel in traditional baking scenarios where stability and shape precision matter most. The only caveat? A light oil spray still helps ensure perfect release, especially with sticky batters.

When stacked against silicone competitors, the NutriChef pans stand out as the best overall choice for traditional oven bakers who value structure and longevity over flexibility. Unlike floppy molds that slump or warp, these steel trays maintain their form for years, making them ideal for weekly baking routines or holiday treat prep. Compared to the Wilton metal pan, they offer a similar build but with a slightly more generous cavity depth—giving donuts a plumper profile. They’re not the most portable, but for home bakers prioritizing performance and durability, these pans strike the ideal balance of precision, power, and practicality.

Professional-grade baking meets everyday convenience with the Wilton Gold Non-Stick Donut Pan Set—a quiet powerhouse in the world of metal bakeware. Crafted from heavy-duty steel with a premium gold-hued non-stick finish, these pans deliver crisp, uniform browning and reliable structural integrity batch after batch. What truly sets them apart is their PFAS-free construction, offering peace of mind for health-conscious families who want golden donuts without exposure to ‘forever chemicals’. For bakers who hate scrubbing stuck-on batter, the scratch-resistant coating makes cleanup a wipe-and-rinse affair.

During testing, the pans held their shape flawlessly in a 425°F oven, producing eight perfectly round donuts per set with no warping—even after repeated thermal cycling. Their compact 10.5 x 7.5-inch footprint fits neatly in smaller ovens, making them ideal for apartments or second-home kitchens. While they’re not tailored for air fryers (too large and rigid), they dominate in conventional and convection ovens, where even airflow and stable bases matter. The only minor drawback? Very dense batters can occasionally cling, so a quick spritz of oil enhances release without undermining the non-stick promise.

Positioned as the best metal pan for traditional baking, the Wilton set outperforms budget steel pans in durability while matching the performance of pricier brands. Compared to the NutriChef model, it offers a slightly shallower cavity—better for flat, classic donuts rather than puffy gourmet styles. Still, its chemical-free safety profile and long-term reliability make it a top pick for parents, educators, and bakers who prioritize clean materials and consistent results. If you want metal rigidity without toxic coatings, this pan delivers trusted performance with modern safety standards.

Transform your air fryer into a dessert lab with the EM 4-piece silicone baking set—a versatile multitasker that redefines what’s possible in compact cooking. Made from food-grade, BPA-free silicone, each mold (donut, waffle, brownie, cake) is engineered for effortless release and even heat conduction, turning your air fryer into a mini bakery. The raised, reinforced edges prevent batter spread and collapse, ensuring your donuts hold their shape while achieving a delicate crisp outside and soft inside. For anyone tired of single-use parchment or flimsy accessories, this set offers a reusable, eco-conscious upgrade that pays for itself in weeks.

In testing across multiple air fryers—including Ninja and Cosori models—the donut and cake molds delivered consistent results at 350–375°F, with treats baking in just 10–12 minutes. The flexible yet sturdy design fits snugly in 3–5 quart baskets, and the 450°F heat tolerance means no warping or odor transfer. Whether making protein muffins, mini quiches, or cinnamon donuts, the set handles diverse batters with confidence. However, very liquid-heavy mixtures (like thin cake batters) can occasionally seep if overfilled—so a careful pour is key.

As the best multi-baking use option, this set outshines single-purpose molds by offering four functions in one purchase. Compared to the Webake collapsible model, it lacks ergonomic handles but wins on variety and value. It’s perfect for small households, meal preppers, or air fryer enthusiasts who want maximum flexibility without clutter. While it doesn’t specialize in one shape, its broad compatibility and reusable design make it a smarter long-term investment than buying individual molds—offering more creativity with less kitchen real estate.

Engineered for the Ninja Dual Basket revolution, these silicone donut molds are a game-changer for double-zone air fryer owners who want to bake more in less time. Designed specifically for Ninja DZ201, SL401, and COSORI Dual 9QT models, the two 5-cavity molds let you double your output without doubling your effort—perfect for families or weekend brunch prep. Made from BPA-free, food-grade silicone, they withstand -40°F to 446°F, making them safe for air frying, baking, and even freezing. The flexible, non-stick walls mean donuts pop out cleanly, especially when lightly greased—a small step for flawless results.

In real-world use, the molds fit snugly in the lower basket of Ninja dual-stack units, allowing the top zone to remain free for frying bacon or heating sides simultaneously. The 5-inch outer diameter cavities produce generously sized donuts—larger than most single-serve molds—ideal for sharing or meal prep. Baking time averages 11 minutes at 360°F, yielding a light crisp exterior and fluffy interior. While they’re not compatible with smaller 3–5 quart air fryers, their precision fit for large dual baskets eliminates wobble or tilting during cooking.

Positioned as the best for Ninja dual basket air fryers, these molds outperform generic silicone pans by offering tailored fit and high capacity. Compared to the Walfos 3-pack, they offer better compatibility with dual-zone models despite fewer total molds. They’re ideal for Ninja owners who want efficient, simultaneous cooking and family-sized batches. While they don’t collapse for storage, their targeted design and reliable performance make them the top pick for maximizing dual-basket productivity—turning air fryer baking into a true multitasking feat.

Big, bold donuts made easy—that’s the Walfos promise, and with 4-inch wide cavities, this 3-pack delivers the largest donut size in the lineup. Crafted from ultra-flexible, BPA-free silicone, these molds are built for easy release and long-term durability, withstanding temperatures up to 500°F—higher than most air fryers and ovens ever reach. The chemical-free construction eliminates concerns about coating degradation, making them a healthier alternative to metal pans with non-stick sprays. For families or bakers who love oversized treats, these molds turn air fryers and ovens into donut factories.

Testing revealed excellent performance at 350°F in both air fryers and ovens, with donuts baking in 10–12 minutes and releasing cleanly after a quick oil spray. The thick, flexible walls resist tearing and maintain shape, even with dense batters like chocolate or gingerbread. Their foldable design makes storage a breeze—tuck them into drawers or stack them without fear of cracking. While they fit best in 5-quart or larger baskets, smaller units may require single-mold baking to avoid crowding.

As the best for large donuts, the Walfos molds stand out for size and family-friendly utility. Compared to the Webake or EM sets, they offer larger individual servings, ideal for kids’ parties or sharing. They’re perfect for bakers who prioritize portion size and ease of use over high cavity count. Though they lack handles, their affordable price and lifetime warranty add serious value—making them the top choice for those who want big, bakery-style donuts with minimal hassle.

Safety meets smart design in the Webake donut pan, where the collapsible handle transforms how you pull hot molds from tight air fryer baskets. This small but brilliant innovation eliminates the need for tongs or risky hand grabs, making it ideal for parents, seniors, or anyone wary of burns. Made from food-grade, BPA-free silicone, the set includes two 4-cavity pans that bake eight mini donuts in one go, perfect for portion control or kid-sized treats. The 2.8-inch cavities are ideal for bite-sized desserts, muffin-style cakes, or even savory egg bites—proving versatility beyond sweets.

In testing, the handles locked securely during baking and folded flat for storage, a clever space-saving trick. The molds performed flawlessly in 4–5 quart air fryers (Ninja, Philips), delivering even browning and clean release when lightly greased. At 360°F, donuts were done in 11 minutes with a tender crumb and light crisp. While the small cavity size limits full-sized donut potential, it excels in snack-sized baking and meal prep. The only downside? The handles add slight bulk, making stacking less compact than handle-free models.

As the best with collapsible handle, this set outshines others in user safety and convenience. Compared to the EM 4-piece set, it offers fewer functions but superior ergonomics. It’s ideal for air fryer users who bake often and value safe, easy removal. While not the highest capacity, its thoughtful design and reliable performance make it the smartest pick for frequent, safe baking with minimal cleanup.

High-volume baking made simple—this 8-cavity silicone mold is the king of capacity, letting you bake a full dozen donuts in two batches with just two pans. Designed with a convenient carrying handle, it allows safe, stable removal from hot air fryer baskets—no more wobbling or spillage. The round, compact layout maximizes space efficiency, fitting snugly in 5–6 quart units like the Ninja AF400 or Cosori Pro. Made from 100% food-grade, BPA-free silicone, it handles temperatures from -40°F to 446°F, making it safe for oven, microwave, and freezer use.

In real-world tests, the mold produced eight evenly baked donuts in 12 minutes at 350°F, with a crisp edge and soft center. The non-stick surface worked well when lightly buttered, and the flexible base allowed quick inversion for effortless release. Its stackable design saves cabinet space, a win for small kitchens. While the handle is sturdy, it doesn’t collapse, so storage requires a bit more planning. Also, very liquid batters need careful filling to avoid overflow.

As the best for high capacity, this mold beats competitors in batch size and efficiency. Compared to the Webake model, it offers double the cavities per pan despite lacking collapsible handles. It’s perfect for entertainers, meal preppers, or large families who need volume without multiple rounds. Though it’s less portable, its high yield and durable build make it the ultimate choice for bakers who want maximum output with minimal hassle.