8 Best Air Fryer Plate Replacements of 2026

This dual-pack stainless steel crisper plate is a game-changer for Ninja Foodi owners who demand durability and performance. Crafted from food-grade stainless steel with a unique airflow design, these trays ensure even heat distribution—crucial for achieving that perfect crisp on chicken wings, steak, or fries. The non-toxic, BPA-free construction meets FDA standards, offering peace of mind for health-conscious cooks, while the Teflon non-stick coating makes cleanup a breeze, especially after heavy use.

In real-world testing, the 8.1 x 5.5-inch dimensions fit snugly in the Ninja DZ090 and DZ201 models, allowing for consistent air circulation without rattling or warping—even at 400°F. Whether searing vegetables or dehydrating fruit, the perforated surface delivers reliable browning and texture. However, it’s critical to note: this plate does not fit the 10-quart Ninja models, and aggressive scrubbing can degrade the non-stick layer over time, so hand washing with the included magic cleaning cloth is recommended for longevity.

Compared to single-plate alternatives, this 2-pack offers exceptional value for households that rotate cooking batches or want a spare on hand. While the GCQFZ PowerXL pan wins on price, this Ninja-specific set outperforms in fit and finish. It’s ideal for daily Ninja users who prioritize consistent performance and durability—and if you own a 6 or 8-quart model, this replacement plate delivers superior build and thoughtful design without the premium price tag of OEM parts.

For budget-savvy users of compact air fryers, this 6.1-inch round grill pan delivers surprising performance without breaking the bank. Made from food-grade stainless steel and featuring a double-layer PTFE non-stick coating, it resists flaking and ensures food releases cleanly—ideal for delicate items like fish or sticky chicken wings. The integrated handle is a small but critical detail, allowing safe, secure removal from the hot basket, which many no-name replacements overlook.

Testing reveals it fits Chefman, Dash PowerXL, and Bella 1.6–2 QT models like a glove, with no wobbling or airflow blockage. At high temperatures, the pan holds up well, though prolonged exposure to sharp utensils can scratch the coating. It’s dishwasher-safe, but users should wait until it cools completely—thermal shock from cold water on a hot pan could warp the metal. While it handles fries and veggies admirably, it’s less effective for bulkier meals due to its limited surface area.

When stacked against pricier options like the HQT Instant Pot pan, this model lacks premium materials but excels as a no-frills, functional fix for smaller fryers. It’s the go-to for occasional users or students who need a reliable, low-cost replacement. For less than $10, it offers solid performance and smart design, making it a standout in the budget replacement market—a true example of essential over excessive.

Ninja AF100 series owners finally have a precise, high-performance replacement that mirrors OEM quality without the markup. This 8.2 x 8.2-inch ceramic-coated crisper plate stands out with its advanced non-stick surface, which outlasts standard Teflon in repeated use—especially when roasting sticky sauces or sugary glazes. The perforated design boosts crispiness, making it ideal for crispy fries, golden onion rings, or grilled chicken with minimal oil.

During testing, the pan showed excellent heat retention and warp resistance across hundreds of cycles. The comfortable handle allows easy basket extraction, and the ceramic coating wipes clean with minimal effort, though abrasive pads will degrade it over time. It fits Ninja AF100 to AF161 models perfectly, but won’t work with newer Foodi DualZone units. One limitation: while the airflow is efficient, the solid center section slightly restricts circulation compared to fully perforated alternatives like the COSORI B0BHKN1NCG model.

For users replacing a damaged original tray, this pan offers near-identical performance at a fraction of the cost. It’s the smart choice for Ninja legacy model owners who want longevity and consistency. Compared to the 2-pack B0BD4VG7QY, it’s less of a value play but wins in build refinement and food release, making it the premium pick for single-unit replacement.

Engineered specifically for COSORI 5 QT models, this 8.1 x 8.1-inch stainless steel crisper plate combines precision fit with pro-grade performance. Made from 304 food-grade stainless steel, it resists corrosion and warping, while the whirlwind airflow design ensures even crisping—no more rotating food halfway through. The central handle makes it safe to pull from the basket, and the Teflon coating releases food effortlessly, even after caramelized marinades.

In real kitchen use, it excels at batch cooking fries, wings, or roasted veggies, with no hot spots or uneven browning. The 4 included rubber bumpers prevent internal scratches, a subtle but important touch for preserving your fryer’s interior. It’s fully dishwasher-safe, though cooling before washing is advised. One minor downside: the coating isn’t as durable as ceramic, so long-term users should avoid metal utensils.

Against competitors, this pan punches above its weight. While the GCQFZ PowerXL model is cheaper, this one offers better material quality and fit accuracy. It’s the top choice for COSORI owners who want OEM-level reliability without waiting for brand parts. For frequent cooks needing a trustworthy replacement, this pan delivers precision, performance, and peace of mind—a clear win in the mid-price bracket.

The GCQFZ oval grill pan earns its “Best Overall” title by blending affordability, smart design, and universal appeal for PowerXL Vortex Pro 6 QT users. Measuring 8.67 x 8.67 inches, its stainless steel build with non-stick coating handles high-heat searing without warping, while the whirlwind airflow pattern ensures even crisping—perfect for steak, fish fillets, or loaded nachos. The center handle makes removal safe and simple, a must for hot, oil-laden meals.

In daily use, it outperforms many OEM trays with zero sticking and easy cleaning, even after burnt-on cheese or sugary glazes. The 6 rubber bumpers protect the fryer basket from scratches, and the included magic cloth helps preserve the coating. It fits PowerXL Vortex Pro 6 QT flawlessly, but won’t work with larger or ClearCook models. While the steel is durable, the coating can degrade if scrubbed with harsh pads—stick to soft sponges.

Compared to the B092ZYBRZS 7 QT model, this pan offers better value for mid-sized fryers. It’s the ideal pick for budget-focused users who refuse to compromise on performance or safety. For families or frequent cooks, this replacement delivers premium features at an entry-level price, making it the smartest all-around investment in the lineup.

If you own a PowerXL Vortex 7 QT, this 10.3 x 9.5-inch oval crisper plate is the largest, most capable replacement available. Its spacious food-grade stainless steel surface with enameled non-stick coating handles family-sized meals with ease—roast a whole chicken or a full tray of fries without overcrowding. The whirlwind airflow design ensures even cooking, while the handle and bumper system make it safe and fryer-friendly.

Real-world testing shows it maintains shape and performance even after repeated 400°F cycles, with no warping or coating peeling when cleaned gently. The 4 rubber bumpers prevent basket scratches, and the magic cleaning cloth helps extend coating life. However, due to its size, it’s not compatible with smaller models, and users must measure carefully—some 6 QT units may not accommodate it.

Next to the GCQFZ 6 QT model, this pan trades portability for raw cooking capacity. It’s the best fit for large-household users who need maximum surface area and durability. While slightly pricier, it justifies the cost with superior size and build, making it the undisputed champion for big-batch cooking—a must-have for entertainers or meal preppers.

The HQT grill plate stands out as the most upgraded build in the replacement market, designed for Instant Pot Vortex Plus 6 QT XL users who want long-term durability. Measuring 9.84 x 9.45 inches (with bumpers), it’s crafted from upgraded food-grade carbon steel and features a double-layer non-stick coating that resists chipping—ideal for frequent use. The handle design ensures safe removal, and the enhanced airflow delivers consistent browning across all foods.

In testing, it outlasted standard pans with no coating flaking after months of daily use. The 4 rubber bumpers protect the fryer, and the magic cloth keeps cleaning safe. It fits Vortex Plus 6 QT XL and 5.7 QT models, but not ClearCook or Odor Erase versions—a key detail to verify. While it handles high heat well, sudden cooling can stress the metal, so cooling before washing is essential.

Against the GXF B086PGQ5TM model, this one offers better material and coating tech. It’s the premium pick for power users who cook daily and demand reliability and longevity. For serious home chefs, this pan delivers professional-grade performance, making it the top-tier upgrade worth the investment.

The GXF grill pan is a solid, no-surprises fit for Instant Pot Vortex 5.7 to 6 QT models, offering reliable performance at a fair price. Its 9.1 x 9.5-inch stainless steel tray with Teflon non-stick coating delivers even crisping and easy food release—perfect for weeknight fries, grilled veggies, or chicken tenders. The center handle allows safe basket removal, and the 4 rubber bumpers protect your fryer’s interior from scratches.

In practice, it handles daily cooking with ease, though the coating isn’t as durable as ceramic or double-layer options—avoid metal tools to extend its life. It fits Vortex Plus 6 QT XL and 5.7 QT models, but not ClearCook or Odor Erase versions, so double-check compatibility. It’s dishwasher-safe, but like all non-stick pans, hand washing preserves the surface longer.

Compared to the HQT B09S5MS5M9, it lacks the upgraded materials but wins on affordability and simplicity. It’s the best for Instant Pot users who want a dependable, OEM-like replacement without overspending. For casual to moderate cooks, this pan offers consistent results and smart design, making it a practical, no-fuss choice.