6 Best Ninja Air Fryer Replacement Trays 2026

This dual-component powerhouse delivers a rare combo of precision engineering and practical versatility, making it a standout among replacement trays for the Ninja SP101 series. The stainless steel mesh basket ensures superior airflow, crisping foods evenly from all angles—ideal for golden fries or succulent chicken wings—while the non-stick baking tray offers a smooth surface perfect for delicate items like fish or roasted veggies. Designed specifically for users frustrated by flimsy, warped OEM pans, this set solves durability and performance issues in one sleek package, restoring your air fryer’s original efficiency.

In real-world testing, the mesh basket shines when air frying high-moisture foods, thanks to its open-grid design that prevents steam buildup and sogginess. The baking tray maintains even heat distribution up to 450℉, with no warping or off-gassing, and both pieces fit snugly in the SP101 cavity without rattling. While the non-stick coating performs well with light oils, aggressive scrubbing may degrade it over time—stick to soft sponges. It’s not compatible with larger models like the SP151, so double-check your unit before buying.

Compared to basic single-tray replacements, this BRIKINTE set offers balanced functionality akin to the Crumb Tray Replacement for SP101 (B0DWXQ37BT), but without the added Teflon mats. It’s best suited for SP101 owners who want restaurant-grade crispness and easy food release without sacrificing build quality. If you’re after maximized airflow and dual-use flexibility, this kit outperforms simpler alternatives—though it lacks the cleaning extras found in combo kits.

This no-frills workhorse redefines value with its broad compatibility and smart thermal design, making it a go-to fix for Ninja AF101, AF150, and AF161 users battling worn-out crisper plates. The heat-flowing air hole pattern ensures rapid, uniform cooking—crucial for achieving that coveted crunch without flipping—while the food-grade material eliminates concerns about chemical leaching during high-temp cycles. It directly addresses the all-too-common pain point of uneven browning and stuck-on residue, offering a reliable, budget-conscious refresh for aging air fryers.

During daily use, the tray slides smoothly into the basket with a reassuringly snug fit, staying stable even when loaded with frozen nuggets or thick-cut potatoes. Its compact, perforated surface promotes excellent air circulation, delivering consistent results across proteins and veggies. While it handles standard portions well, the smaller size can be limiting for family meals, and the non-stick layer, though effective, requires gentle cleaning to avoid scratching. Still, for quick weeknight meals or reheating leftovers, it performs like a factory-original with zero fuss.

When stacked against the Air Fryer Grill Pan B09PMGF5VN, this model offers similar performance but skips the handle and bonus cleaning accessories—making it leaner but more affordable. It’s ideal for budget-focused users who need a single, dependable replacement without frills. For those seeking maximum bang for the buck, this tray beats pricier options handily, especially if you own multiple compatible Ninja models and want one tray to rule them all.

Engineered for effortless handling and everyday durability, this replacement crisper plate brings a thoughtful upgrade to Ninja AF101, AF150, and AF161 owners tired of wrestling hot trays barehanded. The integrated handle is a game-changer—allowing safe removal mid-cycle without tongs or mitts—while the double-layer non-stick enamel resists scratches and simplifies cleanup after sticky glazes or battered foods. Crafted from FDA-compliant, BPA-free material, it supports healthy cooking without odor or chemical transfer, solving the lingering taste issues some users report with generic trays.

Real-world tests show it handles everything from crispy tater tots to juicy salmon fillets with consistent browning, thanks to its 8.2-inch round design that maximizes basket contact and airflow. The even heat spread prevents hot spots, and the tray remains warp-free even after repeated 400℉ cycles. While it fits several Ninja models, precise measurement is key—some users report tight fits in older units. The non-stick performance holds up well with hand washing, but abrasive pads can degrade the coating over time.

Compared to the bare-bones B0DL5QRLG9, this version offers clear functional advantages—notably the handle and enhanced coating—while staying competitively priced. It’s perfect for home cooks who prioritize safety, convenience, and long-term reliability. If you want a well-rounded upgrade that adds usability without overspending, this tray delivers more tangible benefits than basic replacements—especially with the included cleaning cloth and bumpers.

Built for DualZone dominance, this twin-pack crisper plate set is a masterstroke for Ninja Foodi DZ090 and DZ201 owners who demand high-volume, even cooking across both baskets. The 8.1 x 5.5-inch oblong design perfectly matches the asymmetric chamber of DualZone models, ensuring full coverage and optimal contact with food—critical for grilling steaks or roasting veggies in bulk. Its unique airflow channels promote 360-degree heat penetration, turning out uniformly crispy results whether you’re air frying wings or dehydrating apple slices.

In practice, the Teflon-coated surface delivers superb non-stick performance, effortlessly releasing sticky barbecue ribs or breaded shrimp with minimal oil. The two-pack format is ideal for rotating use—one pan cooks while the other soaks—reducing downtime and boosting kitchen efficiency. While the coating is delicate and requires non-abrasive cleaning, the dishwasher-safe design makes maintenance easy. It’s incompatible with 10-quart models like the DZ401, so confirm your model number before purchase.

Next to the single-pan B09PMGF5VN, this option offers superior scalability and convenience for large households or frequent entertainers. It’s the clear choice for DualZone users who need durable, high-performing trays that match their machine’s dual-basket workflow. For those seeking maximum utility and consistent results, this set outshines single replacements—offering better long-term value despite a higher upfront cost.

This industrial-grade crumb tray sets a new benchmark for durability with its premium 304 stainless steel construction—making it the most robust option for Ninja Foodi DT200, DT251, and XL Pro oven owners battling flimsy, rust-prone originals. Unlike coated or composite trays, this one resists warping, corrosion, and high heat up to 450℉, delivering long-term reliability that cheaper alternatives simply can’t match. It’s engineered for users who prioritize cleanliness, safety, and oven integrity, catching grease and crumbs before they smoke or damage internal components.

In real-world use, the 14.3” x 11.8” large-format tray fits seamlessly beneath the cooking chamber, acting as a first line of defense against messy drips during roasting or air frying. It slides in and out smoothly, collects debris efficiently, and wipes clean with minimal effort—though stubborn grease may require mild soap. While it lacks non-stick properties, its inert metal surface won’t degrade or emit fumes, making it safer for high-temp cooking. Users must verify model compatibility, as it only fits specific DT-series ovens.

Compared to the Teflon-mat-inclusive B0DWXQ37BT, this tray trades convenience extras for raw durability and material superiority. It’s ideal for purists and heavy users who want a maintenance-free, lifelong solution instead of disposable liners. If you value build quality and long-term performance over added accessories, this 304 steel tray is unmatched—offering better resilience and peace of mind than any coated or composite alternative.

This cleaning-centric dream team combines a precision-fit crumb tray with four reusable Teflon mats, delivering the most comprehensive solution for SP101 and SP151 owners obsessed with spotless maintenance. The food-grade crumb tray catches every breadcrumb and oil drip, while the 480℉-rated Teflon liners create a slick barrier that prevents food from bonding to the tray—ideal for sticky marinades or sugary glazes that typically gum up air fryer interiors. It solves the universal headache of baked-on messes, transforming cleanup from a chore into a wipe-and-go routine.

In daily testing, the Teflon mats proved nearly self-cleaning—most spills lift off with a damp cloth or quick rinse, and they’re safe for dishwasher use when needed. The tray itself fits flush in SP101/SP151 models, with no shifting or noise during operation. While the mats can discolor over time with heavy use, they retain their non-stick integrity remarkably well. One caveat: users must monitor temperature to stay within the 480℉ limit, avoiding broil settings that could degrade the coating.

Against the stainless steel B0FX3WBWCS, this kit sacrifices metal durability for unmatched cleaning ease—making it the top pick for frequent cooks who hate scrubbing. It’s perfect for families or meal preppers who run their air fryer multiple times a day and want instant tray protection. If effortless maintenance and time-saving convenience matter more than raw material toughness, this combo outperforms all others—offering smarter functionality than trays without liners.