8 Cuisinart Air Fryer Replacement Trays 2026

If you’re tired of warped, flimsy trays that can’t survive a month of weekday air frying, the 2-pack stainless steel mesh tray set from this Cuisinart-compatible replacement is a game-changer. Measuring 12.4 x 11 inches with a low-profile 0.78″ depth, these trays are engineered for optimal airflow and even browning—no more soggy fries or unevenly cooked chicken. Crafted from food-grade stainless steel, they resist warping up to 480°F and deliver the crisp, golden results that health-conscious home cooks crave, all while solving the all-too-common pain point of single-tray replacements running out too fast.

In real-world testing across multiple Cuisinart TOA-60, TOA-65, and TOA-70 units, these trays slid in effortlessly and maintained structural integrity through repeated cycles of roasting Brussels sprouts, baking salmon, and reheating pizza. The open mesh design promotes 360° heat circulation, ensuring consistent texture without hot spots. While they’re dishwasher-safe and easy to clean, we recommend hand drying to preserve the finish over time. The only caveat? Their shallow depth makes them less ideal for saucy or oily foods that might drip through—use the solid pan underneath when needed.

Compared to single-tray options like the B0CSMXBM66, this 2-pack offers unmatched value for frequent users or families who batch-cook meals. It outshines budget picks by eliminating the need for constant replacements, and unlike non-stick coated versions, it won’t degrade after a few months. If you want long-term durability and convenience without sacrificing performance, this set stands tall—even against pricier combos. It’s the smart investment for those who treat their air fryer toaster oven like a daily kitchen MVP.

For users who prioritize effortless cleanup and sleek performance, this mirror-finish stainless steel tray delivers a refreshingly simple upgrade for Cuisinart TOA-060 and TOA-065 models. The smooth, nonstick surface doesn’t rely on chemical coatings—instead, it uses a precision-polished finish that naturally resists food buildup, making it a standout for those wary of peeling non-stick layers. Its durable steel construction handles high-heat roasting with confidence, solving the common frustration of stained, sticky trays that cling to charred bits after every use.

During testing, the pan proved exceptional for low-moisture foods like roasted vegetables, fish fillets, and reheated leftovers, releasing cleanly with just a wipe. The mirror polish not only looks premium but also enhances heat reflection for more consistent browning across the surface. While it lacks a non-stick coating, its easy-release performance rivals coated alternatives, especially when lightly oiled. However, sticky sauces or sugary glazes can bond more aggressively, requiring a quick soak—though still easier to clean than worn original trays.

When stacked against the B0CVVHF7W2 non-stick model, this pan trades slick release for longer-term resilience and chemical-free safety. It’s less versatile for messy foods but shines as a low-maintenance, high-durability solution for clean-eating households. Ideal for minimalists and eco-conscious users who want a no-fuss, lifetime-grade tray without coatings that flake over time. While it doesn’t match the multi-piece utility of combo sets, it offers superior cleanability in a single, well-executed design—a quiet win for everyday simplicity.

When crispy, oil-free results are the mission, this non-stick mesh basket steps up as a top-tier performer for Cuisinart TOA-60, TOA-65, and TOA-70 owners. The perforated steel design maximizes air circulation, turning frozen fries into golden crunch and chicken wings into crackling perfection—no flipping required. Coated with a food-grade, PFOA-free non-stick layer, it tackles the biggest pain point of stuck-on food, making cleanup a wipe-and-rinse affair. But here’s the catch: preheating is mandatory—skip the 300°F/10-minute warm-up and risk warping, which could shorten its lifespan.

In daily use, the basket handled everything from delicate fish to dense sweet potato cubes with impressive consistency. The 2.3-inch depth adds containment for taller items, preventing spills during mid-cycle checks—something shallower trays struggle with. It’s dishwasher-safe, and baked-on residue softened after a 10-minute soak, peeling off without scrubbing. However, avoid steel wool or abrasive pads; they’ll compromise the non-stick surface over time. While it excels in texture and ease, prolonged high-heat exposure without preheating can lead to bending—so discipline is key.

Next to the basic stainless steel B0CSJYQMT3, this model brings superior release performance and deeper cooking space, making it ideal for messy or delicate foods. It’s a notch above entry-level trays but doesn’t carry the multi-accessory value of full sets like B0CSCYXYP1. For users who demand crispy results and hate scrubbing, this is the go-to non-stick workhorse—just respect the preheat rule. It balances performance and practicality, outclassing bare metal trays in convenience without inflating the price.

This dual-component set—featuring both a mesh basket and solid tray—is engineered for those who want professional-level heat control in their Cuisinart TOA-060 and TOA-065 units. The elevated mesh basket enables 360° air circulation, crisping food evenly on all sides, while the solid pan serves as a backup for broiling or catching drips. Made from food-grade stainless steel with a polished finish, it resists corrosion and won’t leach chemicals, addressing health concerns tied to coated alternatives. For users tired of unevenly cooked meals, this combo delivers restaurant-style results at home.

In real cooking scenarios, the basket excelled at air-fried chicken tenders and roasted veggies, achieving crispness without dryness thanks to optimal airflow and heat reflection. The tray doubled as a cooling rack and baking surface, adding unexpected utility. Both pieces are dishwasher-safe and resistant to warping, though heavy carbon buildup from fatty foods required soaking. While compatible only with TOA-060 and TOA-065 models, its precision fit ensures no rattling or misalignment during operation—a common issue with generic trays.

Compared to the single-basket B0CSMXBM66, this set offers far greater versatility, letting you switch between convection frying and baking seamlessly. It doesn’t include extra racks like the B0CSCYXYP1 set but focuses on core performance and heat efficiency. Ideal for serious home cooks who want maximum crisp with minimal compromise, it outperforms basic trays in functionality. While not the cheapest, it delivers premium airflow and build quality that justifies its place in a high-use kitchen.

For the kitchen multitasker, this 3-piece non-stick set—featuring a baking pan, fry basket, and wire rack—transforms your Cuisinart TOA-60/65/70 into a full-function convection powerhouse. The 12.2 x 11-inch dimensions ensure perfect fitment, while the elevated wire rack enables dual-layer cooking, letting you roast veggies below and crisp chicken above—no flavor transfer, no extra dishes. Made from corrosion-resistant steel with a smooth non-porous finish, it resists stains and odors, solving the stinky, discolored tray problem that plagues frequent users.

During testing, the set proved invaluable for meal prepping and holiday cooking, where space and efficiency matter. The basket delivered even crisping, the pan handled casseroles and bakes, and the rack doubled as a cooling stand—true versatility in one package. All components are easy to wipe down or hand wash, though sticky residues benefit from a short soak. While not dishwasher-safe (a rare con), the low-maintenance surface still beats scrubbing burnt-on gunk. The only downside? Slight wobble when stacking, so load items evenly.

Stacked against the 2-pack B0CYSJTL8X, this set offers more functionality for complex meals, though at a slight cleaning cost. It doesn’t have the dishwasher convenience of the B0CSJYQMT3, but its multi-tier cooking capability is unmatched. Perfect for families, batch-cookers, or entertainers, it turns a single appliance into a multi-tasking marvel. If you want maximum kitchen flexibility, this is the most complete upgrade—balancing durability, design, and real-world utility better than any standalone tray.

When easy cleanup is non-negotiable, this ultra-smooth, dishwasher-safe mesh tray earns its title as the most hassle-free Cuisinart replacement on the market. Measuring 12.4 x 11 inches, it fits TOA-60, TOA-65, and TOA-70 models like a factory original, with a low 0.78″ profile that maximizes interior space. Made from food-grade steel with a non-stick finish, it resists warping up to 480°F and slides effortlessly into dishwashers—no pre-soaking, no scrubbing. For users drowning in post-cook cleanup, this tray is a lifesaver.

In testing, it handled everything from frozen nuggets to roasted carrots with minimal sticking, and baked-on splatters loosened after a 5-minute soak. The open mesh promotes airflow, though not quite as aggressively as deeper baskets—ideal for lighter frying tasks. The mandatory preheat step (300°F for 10 minutes) prevents warping, a small price for longevity. While it lacks a wire rack or extra pan, its single-minded focus on cleanability makes it ideal for quick meals and weekday cooking.

Against the B0CVVHF7W2, it’s nearly identical—but priced lower and with slightly shallower depth. It doesn’t offer the dual-layer cooking of B0CSCYXYP1 or the polish of B0CSMXBM66, but it nails the basics better than most. For users who value simplicity and speed, this is the most reliable dishwasher-safe workhorse—delivering consistent performance and effortless maintenance without bells and whistles.

If you’re looking for the complete Cuisinart air fryer upgrade, this combo pack of mesh basket and solid baking sheet stands as the most well-rounded solution for TOA-60, TOA-65, and TOA-70 owners. The dual design lets you air fry on the mesh basket for crispiness or bake on the flat pan for delicate items—maximum versatility in one purchase. Both pieces are crafted from food-grade stainless steel, resisting warping up to 480°F and passing the long-term durability test with flying colors.

In real use, the mesh basket delivered restaurant-level crisp, while the solid pan doubled as a cooling rack, strainer, and storage tray—a true multi-tasker. The 12.4 x 11-inch sizing ensures perfect fit, and the open design contains splatters without blocking airflow. Like others in this category, preheating is critical to prevent bending—skip it, and you risk early failure. Cleaning is a breeze: dishwasher-safe and non-stick, with residue lifting after a quick soak.

Compared to the 2-pack B0CYSJTL8X, this set adds functional diversity without sacrificing durability. It doesn’t include a wire rack like B0CSCYXYP1, but the basket-and-pan combo covers 90% of cooking needs. For users who want the best balance of performance, flexibility, and build quality, this is the top all-in-one choice—delivering pro-grade results with home-kitchen practicality.

For budget-conscious cooks who refuse to compromise on crisp texture and easy cleanup, this Cuisinart-branded non-stick basket is a no-brainer upgrade. The perforated steel design ensures maximum air circulation, delivering the golden, crunchy finish that defines great air frying—think fried chicken without the grease. With a factory-grade non-stick coating, food releases cleanly, and cleanup takes seconds—just wipe or toss in the dishwasher. Its perfect compatibility with TOA-60, TOA-65, and ANS-TOA2528 models means no guesswork or misfits.

In testing, it outperformed generic trays in heat retention and structural rigidity, showing zero warping even after weeks of daily use. The smooth interior resists staining, and baked-on bits lifted with minimal soaking. Unlike third-party baskets, it carries a lifetime warranty—a rare promise that speaks volumes about its built-to-last confidence. While it lacks a solid pan or rack, its single-purpose excellence makes it ideal for fry-focused households.

Against the B0CVVHF7W2, it offers better brand assurance and warranty, though at a slightly higher cost. It doesn’t match the multi-piece utility of B0CSCYXYP1, but for pure air-fry performance on a budget, it’s unmatched. If you want Cuisinart-quality results without paying for extras, this is the smart, no-risk choice—delivering reliability, crispness, and peace of mind in one sleek silver basket.