7 Best Ninja Air Fryer Crumb Tray Replacements 2026

This game-changing crumb tray replacement delivers exceptional value by bundling durability with a full set of reusable oven liners—perfect for SP101 and SP151 owners tired of messy cleanups. Crafted with high-temperature resistance up to 480°F, the tray and Teflon-lined mats stand up to daily air frying without warping, while the non-stick surface ensures zero food residue sticks around. It directly tackles the pain point of greasy, crumb-clogged ovens, making post-meal maintenance nearly effortless.

In real-world use, this combo shines when roasting chicken wings or baking sticky glazed ribs—foods that typically leave behind stubborn splatters. The tray slides in and out smoothly, and paired with the included liners, you can simply lift and wipe clean in seconds. While the tray itself performs admirably, the silicone-like liners do better with light-to-medium cooking loads; heavy grease can seep at the edges if not monitored. Still, for weeknight dinners and batch-prepped meals, it’s a cleaning powerhouse.

Compared to pricier stainless steel alternatives, this model trades long-term metal durability for immediate cost efficiency and added accessories. It’s ideal for budget-conscious households or those who prioritize convenience over longevity. While it won’t match the heft of 304 stainless steel trays, the inclusion of four reusable liners gives it an edge over bare-bones replacements—offering broader functionality at a lower entry cost than most standalone metal trays.

For owners of the Ninja Foodi Double Oven DCT series, this 304 stainless steel crumb tray is a no-compromise upgrade—engineered to endure relentless high-heat cycles without bending, rusting, or degrading. The food-grade 304 stainless steel not only resists temperatures beyond standard air frying but also eliminates the fear of chemical coatings flaking off over time, a common concern with non-metal trays. Its precise 12.8 x 12.6-inch footprint ensures a seamless fit in DCT400, DCT451, and related models, solving the frustration of ill-fitting third-party parts.

During testing with frequent roasting and broiling cycles, the tray caught every crumb and drip without warping—even after weeks of 450°F+ use. The smooth, non-porous surface prevents grease from bonding, so a quick wipe or rinse is all it takes to restore cleanliness. Unlike coated or plastic trays, this one doesn’t retain odors or stains from burnt-on cheese or marinades. However, its rigidity means it has zero flexibility, so if your oven’s interior dimensions are even slightly off, installation becomes a tight squeeze.

When stacked against polymer-based trays, this model wins on longevity and heat resilience, though it lacks the bonus accessories seen in lower-tier kits. It’s best suited for serious home chefs who run their double ovens hard and want a forever replacement that won’t degrade. While it costs more than basic trays, its build quality and compatibility with high-output models justify the investment—especially when compared to flimsier trays that degrade after a few months of heavy use.

If you own an SP201, SP301, or FT301 Ninja Foodi, this 304 stainless steel crumb tray is a precision-engineered solution that brings industrial-grade resilience to countertop cooking. Built to handle temperatures up to 480°F, the tray resists warping and corrosion far better than plastic or coated alternatives, making it ideal for daily air frying, roasting, and broiling. Its 13.2 x 12.9-inch dimensions align perfectly with the SP-series ovens, delivering a secure fit that prevents shifting during operation—a common flaw in off-brand trays.

In practical use, the tray excels at catching grease and crumbs during crispy skin roasts or bacon-heavy meals, preserving oven hygiene and reducing smoke from burnt debris. The nonstick finish isn’t a coating—it’s inherent to the polished steel, so there’s no risk of peeling over time. Cleaning is straightforward: slide it out, discard crumbs, and wipe with a damp cloth or toss in the sink. That said, tight oven clearances can make removal slightly awkward, especially when hot, so tongs or gloves are recommended.

Compared to the SP101-focused models, this tray offers superior material quality and broader model coverage, including FT and SP351 variants. It lacks the bonus liners of budget kits, but its all-metal construction outlasts them by years. It’s the go-to choice for users who want a low-maintenance, permanent fix without recurring liner replacements. While similar in price to some accessory bundles, it delivers better long-term value through sheer durability than kits with short-lived add-ons.

This versatile crumb tray combo stands out with exceptional compatibility, fitting not just SP101 and SP151 models but also extending to SP201 and SP301 ovens—making it a rare universal solution for Ninja owners with multiple units. The tray, paired with four 480°F-rated black PTFE liners, offers a dual-layer defense against mess, letting users line the pan for ultra-easy cleanup or use the tray solo for crispier results. The BPA- and PFOA-free materials ensure safety, addressing health concerns tied to lower-grade non-stick coatings.

Real-world testing shows the liners dramatically reduce scrubbing time after messy bakes like marinated drumsticks or cheesy casseroles. The non-stick surface works impressively—residue wipes off with minimal effort, and the dishwasher-safe design adds convenience. However, the liners can curl at high temps if not weighted down, and prolonged use above 450°F may shorten their lifespan. The tray itself is sturdy but lacks the heft of metal, so it’s best for moderate daily use rather than commercial-level cooking.

Compared to stainless steel alternatives, this model sacrifices longevity for flexibility and affordability, making it ideal for families or casual cooks who want hassle-free cleanup without a premium price tag. While it doesn’t match the ruggedness of 304 steel, the inclusion of four durable liners gives it a functional advantage over bare trays. For users who cook frequently but don’t want to scrub daily, it offers smarter convenience and broader usability than most single-model replacements.

Dubbed the Best Overall for good reason, this 304 stainless steel crumb tray for the Ninja Foodi DT200, DT201, and DT251 series strikes a masterful balance between rugged construction, precise fit, and universal functionality. The 14.3 x 11.8-inch footprint aligns perfectly with the XL Pro ovens, providing full coverage without interference, while the food-grade 304 steel ensures resistance to warping, rust, and high-heat degradation—common flaws in cheaper alternatives. It’s a no-nonsense, long-term fix for users tired of replacing flimsy trays every few months.

In performance testing, the tray handled everything from buttery croissants to grease-heavy sausages without issue. Crumbs and oil stayed contained, and the smooth, non-porous surface prevented staining even after repeated use. Cleaning is a breeze: just wipe with a damp sponge or rinse—no soaking required. However, due to the tight clearance in the DT series, sliding it in and out when hot requires care to avoid scratching the oven cavity.

Against other metal trays, this model holds its own with excellent build and compatibility, though it doesn’t include liners like budget kits. It’s best for users who prioritize durability and simplicity over added accessories. Compared to the SP-series stainless trays, it offers similar quality with slightly better oven coverage, making it a more versatile investment for owners of the larger Ninja ovens—delivering premium performance without unnecessary frills.

Engineered specifically for the SP101 and its sibling models, this 304 stainless steel crumb tray delivers precision fit and professional-grade resilience in a single, no-frills package. With dimensions of 13.3 x 12.8 inches, it matches the original Ninja tray exactly, eliminating the guesswork that often plagues third-party replacements. The food-safe 304 steel construction ensures it won’t rust, warp, or degrade—even under constant 450°F+ cooking cycles—making it a dependable workhorse for daily air frying.

In real-world use, the tray consistently captured crumbs and oil from toasted sandwiches, roasted veggies, and fried chicken, keeping the oven floor spotless. The nonstick properties of polished steel shine here—food doesn’t bond, and cleanup takes seconds with a quick wipe or rinse. However, like other rigid metal trays, it offers zero flexibility, so users must verify their oven’s internal dimensions before purchase to avoid fit issues.

Compared to the SP101-compatible trays with liners, this model trades extras for pure durability and heat resistance. It’s ideal for purists who want a single, long-lasting replacement without disposable or reusable mats. While it costs slightly more than basic plastic trays, its superior material and exact compatibility make it a smarter long-term investment—outperforming coated trays in both cleanliness and lifespan.

For budget-focused buyers, this SP101/SP151 crumb tray kit offers maximum accessibility without sacrificing core functionality. It includes a new replacement tray and four dishwasher-safe silicone oven mats, delivering a complete cleaning solution at the lowest price point in the lineup. The food-grade materials ensure safety, while the non-stick surface makes post-cook cleanup a breeze—just wipe or rinse, and you’re done. It’s a practical, no-frills fix for users who’ve lost or damaged their original tray and want a quick, affordable replacement.

During testing, the silicone mats proved effective at catching drips from burgers and fish fillets, significantly reducing oven mess. The tray slides in and out smoothly, and both components handle temperatures up to 480°F without issue. However, the mats can slide around during convection cycles, and the tray’s plastic-like material doesn’t feel as premium as stainless steel. Still, for occasional users or second ovens, it’s a reliable, low-cost solution.

Against higher-end models, it lacks the durability of 304 steel but matches them in convenience thanks to the included liners. It’s perfect for students, small households, or backup kitchens where performance matters but budget is tight. While it won’t last as long as metal trays, its value-for-money proposition is unmatched—offering similar ease of use to premium kits at a fraction of the cost.